Cinnamon & Applesauce DonutsSoft, perfectly spiced, dusted with sugar.
Nut SubsA local specialty β looks filled, but isn't. An Ossian in-joke you'll want to be in on.
Donut HolesFree at the counter. That's just how it's done here.
π₯§ Pies, Puffs & Custards
Cream Puffs"Out of this world," and the reviews mean it.
Sugar Cream PieThe Indiana classic β "the best around."
Fruit PiesApple, blueberry, pecan, pumpkin in season (they bake ~1,500 at Thanksgiving).
Γclairs & ProfiterolesFilled, glazed, and worth the napkin.
Chocolate Custard & BrowniesFor the serious chocolate crowd.
π Cakes & Cookies
Coconut Cake"The very best ever," according to more than one regular.
Cupcakes & Layer CakesChocolate, creamy, glazed β grab one or take a whole cake home.
Decorated Sugar Cookies"Huge and very tasty" β and beautifully iced for every holiday.
Custom & Photo Cakes Made to orderBirthdays, showers, celebrations. Call to talk through your order.
A sampling of what the case holds, drawn from years of happy reviews β the day's lineup and prices are best confirmed in person or by phone at (260) 622-4196.
Baker's tip: The fried cinnamon rolls and pecan rolls sell out early, and Saturday mornings move fast. If your heart's set on something, a quick call to set it aside never hurts.